Author: HISTPO_Admin

  • Key Features of the US Constitution: Reaching a Judgement

    Is Madison’s claim that “ambition must be made to counteract ambition” still relevant?

    The Supreme Court’s tariffs ruling in 2026 shows one ambitious branch is still capable of checking another when a case reaches it.

    But the immunity ruling, the impoundment stand-off and DOGE’s rapid restructuring of the federal government tell a different story.

    In the 2020s, ambition sometimes outruns the checks meant to counteract it, at least until the courts catch up.

    The case for: these principles remain effective

    • The judiciary struck down clear executive oversteps on both tariffs (2026) and birthright citizenship (2026), showing constitutional limits still bind presidents in practice, not just in theory.
    • States retain genuine, contested but real autonomy on major policy questions such as cannabis and abortion.
    • Even the worst recent breakdown in bipartisanship, the 2025 shutdown, still eventually produced a cross-party resolution rather than permanent deadlock.

    The case against: these principles are under real strain

    • The Trump v United States immunity ruling narrowed one of the most fundamental checks on presidential power: accountability under ordinary criminal law.
    • Congress’s core Article I power of the purse has been persistently tested by impoundment disputes that remain only partially resolved by the courts.
    • Bipartisanship, never constitutionally guaranteed in the first place, is arguably at its lowest point in modern American history.
    • Executive action increasingly moves faster than the courts can check it, meaning limited government depends on litigation catching up rather than genuine prior restraint.

    Reaching a judgement

    Analysis: Taken together, the evidence suggests the Constitution’s structural principles have not failed. But they increasingly operate with a time lag: oversteps happen first, and correction through the courts follows only later, if at all.

    Evaluation: Madison’s claim still holds in a formal sense, since the judiciary continues to check the other branches when cases reach it. But the sheer number of contested, ongoing disputes covered in this document suggests something else. Ambition is currently testing the system’s checks more aggressively than at almost any point in recent decades, making this a moment of real strain rather than confident stability.

    Check your understanding
    1. “The US Constitution’s principles are more effective on paper than in practice.” To what extent do you agree? You should: use specific evidence from at least two of the four principles covered in this document, address the counter-argument directly, and reach a supported judgement.

    2. Which of the four principles in this document do you think is currently under the most strain? Justify your answer. You could: pick one principle and use the strongest example from its table to support your choice.

    next –

  • Limited Government

    Limited government is, again, not a phrase used in the Constitution.

    It is expressed indirectly through the same mechanisms that create federalism and separation of powers.

    The federal government is only granted specific, enumerated powers. The rest are reserved to the states and the people under the Tenth Amendment.

    Certain actions are also forbidden to government altogether, most clearly in the Bill of Rights (1791).

    Limiting government is therefore best understood as the underlying purpose of the Constitution’s structure, not a standalone clause.

    Figure 5: the three constitutional fences that keep federal power limited.

    ExampleDateVerdictWhy it matters
    Trump v Barbara: the birthright citizenship rulingDecided 30 June 2026UpheldThe Supreme Court struck down, 6-3, an executive order that tried to deny citizenship to children of undocumented parents. This confirmed that the Fourteenth Amendment limits presidential power even when a president acts through a formal executive order rather than ordinary legislation.
    The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE)Established January 2025, ongoingStrainedDOGE has cut federal agencies and staff at speed, without the kind of specific congressional authorisation that several lawsuits say the Constitution requires. Legal challenges continue, but by the time courts rule, much of the practical change has often already happened.
    Disputed impoundment of congressional funding2025, ongoingStrainedWithholding money Congress has already appropriated, through mechanisms like ‘pocket rescissions’, tests the idea that the executive can only spend what the legislature allows. Bipartisan voices, including some Republican senators, have called aspects of this unlawful, yet enforcement has been slow.

    Table note: dates given are decision or establishment dates.

    • Courts continue to act as a meaningful backstop against the clearest constitutional oversteps, as in the birthright citizenship ruling.
    • Rapid, high-volume executive action, such as DOGE’s restructuring of federal agencies, can outpace the ability of courts to intervene in time.
    • Disputes over impoundment show that limiting government is not just about individual rights, but also about who controls spending.
    • In practice, limited government today often depends on litigation catching up after policy has already been implemented, rather than genuine prior restraint.

    Analysis: Limited government today relies heavily on the judiciary to intervene after the fact. The executive branch has shown it will act first and defend its actions in court afterwards, as with DOGE and the IEEPA tariffs.

    Evaluation: The Trump v Barbara ruling shows courts can still draw a hard constitutional line when a case is clear enough. Even so, the sheer scale and speed of recent executive action suggests limited government is being tested more severely than in previous decades, whatever the eventual legal outcome.

    Check your understanding
    1. Identify which parts of the Constitution’s structure serve the purpose of limiting government, given that the phrase itself is not used. You could: list the enumerated powers, the Tenth Amendment and the Bill of Rights, and briefly explain what each contributes.

    2. Evaluate the significance of Trump v Barbara for the principle of limited government. You should: explain what the ruling decided, then judge how far a single court case can be said to meaningfully limit executive power going forward.

    Limited Government – Key Takeaways

    • Courts still strike down the clearest oversteps, such as the attempt to redefine birthright citizenship.
    • But the sheer scale of executive action seen in DOGE means limited government increasingly depends on litigation catching up after the fact.
  • Bipartisanship

    Unlike the other three principles in this section, bipartisanship has no constitutional basis whatsoever.

    It cannot be enshrined in the text because the Founders hoped to avoid the very thing it describes: organised political parties.

    Where it exists today, it exists only as a political norm. It is a voluntary habit of cooperation between lawmakers from different parties, not a rule any court can enforce.

    Figure 4: bipartisanship depends on voluntary cooperation, contrasted with the 2025 shutdown and the Laken Riley Act.

    ExampleDateVerdictWhy it matters
    The 2025 federal government shutdown1 October – 12 November 2025 (43 days)Not upheldA shutdown happens when Congress cannot agree a funding law, so federal agencies must stop non-essential work. This one, the longest in American history, furloughed (temporarily laid off, without pay) roughly 900,000 federal workers after Congress failed to agree on 2026 spending, largely over healthcare subsidies. It is a clear sign of bipartisanship breaking down.
    The vote that finally ended the 2025 shutdownNovember 2025Partially upheldThe Senate voted 60-40 for a compromise deal, with seven Democrats and one independent joining Republicans, and the House passed it 222-209 with six Democrats crossing over. Cooperation returned, but only after weeks of hardship and under significant public pressure.
    The Laken Riley ActPassed January 2025Partially upheldTwelve Senate Democrats joined Republicans to pass this immigration enforcement law, alongside 46 House Democrats. Some campaign groups called this capitulation rather than principled compromise, a reminder that ‘bipartisan’ votes do not always reflect genuine cross-party agreement on the merits.

    Table note: vote figures are for the key procedural or final votes described.

    • The 2025 shutdown shows that, without a constitutional requirement to cooperate, partisan gridlock can bring basic government functions to a halt.
    • Cooperation, when it does appear, often arrives only once the costs of continued conflict become too painful to ignore.
    • Even genuinely bipartisan votes, such as the Laken Riley Act, can reflect political pressure on one side rather than shared conviction.
    • Because bipartisanship depends entirely on voluntary behaviour, it is the most fragile of the four principles covered in this document.

    Analysis: Because bipartisanship was never written into the Constitution, its health depends entirely on political culture rather than legal enforcement, and that culture has clearly deteriorated compared with the Founders’ era.

    Evaluation: The record-length 2025 shutdown is strong evidence that bipartisanship is close to its weakest point in modern history. It has not disappeared entirely, as the Laken Riley Act shows, but what remains often looks more like capitulation under pressure than genuine cross-party agreement.

    Check your understanding
    1. Explain why bipartisanship cannot be enshrined in the Constitution in the same way as the other three principles in this document. You could: refer back to the opening paragraph of this section and the Founders’ original hopes, discussed earlier in this document.

    2. Using the 2025 shutdown and the Laken Riley Act, evaluate whether bipartisanship still functions in American politics today. You should: use both examples, note that they point in different directions, and reach an overall judgement rather than treating them as equally significant.

    Bipartisanship – Key Takeaways

    • This principle was never actually written into the Constitution, and it is rarer than ever in practice.
    • The record-length 2025 shutdown proved that, even though occasional deals like the Laken Riley Act show it isn’t extinct.

  • Separation of Powers and Checks and Balances

    As with federalism, the exact phrases ‘separation of powers’ and ‘checks and balances’ do not appear anywhere in the constitutional text.

    Madison used similar language in Federalist No. 51, but the Constitution itself simply establishes the three branches through its structure.

    Article I creates Congress and its legislative power, Article II creates the presidency and executive power, and Article III creates “one supreme Court” and vests it with judicial power.

    The checks between them are written in as specific tools rather than named as a system. They include the presidential veto and Congress’s power to override it, the Senate’s role in confirming appointments and ratifying treaties, and impeachment.

    One of the most powerful checks of all, judicial review, is not in the text at all. The Supreme Court established its own power to strike down unconstitutional laws in Marbury v Madison (1803).

    Figure 3: how the three branches check and balance one another, and the constitutional basis for each relationship.

    ExampleDateVerdictWhy it matters
    Learning Resources v Trump and Trump v V.O.S. Selections (the IEEPA tariffs case)Decided 20 February 2026UpheldThe Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not let a president impose tariffs, since Article I gives that power to Congress alone. A major, very recent example of the judiciary checking executive overreach on economic policy.
    Trump v United States: presidential immunityDecided 1 July 2024StrainedThe Court granted presidents broad immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts, in a 6-3 ruling. The three dissenting justices argued this weakens one of the most basic checks on a president: accountability under ordinary criminal law.
    Withholding congressionally approved funding (‘impoundment’)2025, ongoingContestedImpoundment means the executive refusing to spend money Congress has already approved. Congressional estimates suggest the executive branch froze, cancelled or blocked in court more than $410 billion in approved funds by September 2025. Part of this used a manoeuvre called a ‘pocket rescission’: cancelling funds so late in the year that they simply expire. The Supreme Court allowed some withholding to continue pending fuller litigation, leaving the underlying dispute unresolved.
    Trump v CASA: limits on nationwide injunctionsDecided 27 June 2025MixedThe Court ruled that federal district courts generally cannot issue nationwide injunctions blocking a policy for everyone, only for the parties actually in the case. This strengthened the executive in the short term by narrowing one judicial tool, even though it left underlying questions, like birthright citizenship, undecided at the time.

    Table note: dates given are decision dates unless stated otherwise.

    • The judiciary remains willing to strike down executive action on relatively clear-cut statutory questions, such as the IEEPA tariffs.
    • The same judiciary has been more cautious when the question involves the President’s core official conduct, as in the immunity ruling.
    • Congress’s control over spending, arguably its most important check, has been tested by impoundment disputes (the executive withholding approved funds) that remain only partially resolved.
    • The judiciary has also placed limits on its own power, restricting nationwide injunctions in Trump v CASA (2025) where the Supreme Court ruled that federal judges lack the authority to issue nationwide injunctions, limiting court orders to provide relief only to the specific plaintiffs involved in the lawsuit, even while executive power was being challenged elsewhere.

    Analysis: The pattern across 2024-2026 suggests the judiciary is more willing to check the executive on discrete, technical statutory questions, such as tariff authority, than on the President’s core official conduct or emergency powers.

    Evaluation: Checks and balances are still functioning, as the tariffs ruling proves. But the immunity decision and the unresolved impoundment dispute suggest the system is under more strain than at almost any point in recent history. The overall verdict must be one of partial, rather than complete, success.

    Check your understanding
    1. Explain how judicial review works as a check on Congress and the President, despite not being written into the Constitution. You could: refer to Marbury v Madison and one of the 2024-2026 examples in the table above.

    2. To what extent did Trump v United States weaken checks and balances? You should: set out what the ruling actually changed, consider the counter-argument that some presidential immunity is necessary for the office to function, then reach a judgement.

    Separation of Powers and Checks and Balance – Key Takeaways

    • The Supreme Court proved checks and balances still bite by striking down the president’s tariffs in 2026.
    • Yet its own immunity ruling and hesitancy over impoundment suggest the executive branch has grown more powerful than Madison likely intended.
  • Federalism

    The word ‘federalism’ itself never appears in the Constitution.

    It is a structural principle that political scientists and lawyers infer from several provisions working together, rather than a single named clause.

    Article I, Section 8 lists the specific, enumerated powers (powers written down and specifically granted) given to Congress, implying that anything not listed remains elsewhere.

    The Tenth Amendment makes this explicit, reserving powers “not delegated to the United States” to the states or the people.

    Article VI‘s Supremacy Clause then settles conflicts by making federal law take priority when the two genuinely clash.

    Figure 2: how power is divided between national, concurrent and state government.

    ExampleDateVerdictWhy it matters
    State-level cannabis legalisation despite the federal Controlled Substances ActOngoing since 2012Upheld in practiceGonzales v Raich (2005) confirmed Congress’s supremacy over cannabis in theory, yet the federal government has mostly chosen not to enforce this against state-legal markets. This shows federalism can survive through selective non-enforcement, even where the constitutional theory points the other way.
    Newsom v Trump: federalisation of the California National GuardJune-October 2025MixedA federal district court ruled in August 2025 that deploying the federalised Guard onto Los Angeles streets broke the Posse Comitatus Act. This 1878 law limits using the military for ordinary domestic policing. The Ninth Circuit separately upheld the President’s underlying power to federalise the Guard at all, and declined to rehear that ruling in October 2025.
    Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization and its aftermath2022, still shaping state law into 2026UpheldBy returning abortion regulation to the states, this ruling produced a genuine patchwork of state law, from near-total bans to broad protection. Whatever one thinks of the outcome, it is a clear demonstration that states can still set sharply different policy within the same country.

    Table note: dates given are decision or event dates. Case citations are given in short form.

    • States have shown they can pursue very different policies from the federal government and from each other, as seen in both cannabis law and abortion law since Dobbs. In June 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, officially overturning Roe v. Wade (1973) and Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) to hold that the U.S. Constitution does not confer a right to abortion.
    • Federal power can still reach into state affairs when a president is determined to test the limits, as Newsom v Trump (a federal legal challenge brought by California Governor Gavin Newsom and the State of California against President Donald Trump over the domestic deployment of state troops) shows.
    • Courts, rather than the Constitution’s text alone, are increasingly where the boundary between state and federal authority actually gets decided.
    • Selective federal enforcement, not just legal rulings, plays a major role in how much real autonomy states enjoy in practice.

    Analysis: Federalism today works less like a fixed constitutional boundary and more like a continually renegotiated relationship between Washington and the states. Courts, rather than the bare text of Article I, the Tenth Amendment or Article VI, usually settle where that boundary currently sits.

    Evaluation: On balance, federalism remains a genuinely effective constraint on federal power, since states have secured real autonomy on issues like cannabis and abortion. However, cases like Newsom v Trump show that a sufficiently determined president can still test, and sometimes push past, those boundaries before the courts intervene.

    Check your understanding
    1. Identify two parts of the Constitution that together create federalism, given that the word itself is not used. You could: look back at the ‘where enshrined’ paragraph above and pick two of the three provisions discussed.

    2. Using the National Guard example, explain why federalism disputes are often decided by courts rather than by the Constitution’s text alone. You could: refer to the specific rulings in Newsom v Trump and what each level of court decided.

    3. Evaluate whether federalism in the United States today is closer to genuine state autonomy or federal supremacy. You should: weigh at least one example of real state autonomy against at least one example of federal override, then reach a clear judgement rather than just describing both sides.

    Federalism – Key Take-Aways

    • States still make real choices on issues like drugs and abortion.
    • But the 2025 National Guard dispute in California shows federal power can still override state wishes when a president is determined enough.
  • The Founding Fathers’ Aims

    When delegates gathered in Philadelphia in 1787 for the Constitutional Convention, they were trying to solve two problems at once.

    The Articles of Confederation (1781-1789), America’s first constitution, had given the national government so little power that it could not reliably raise tax revenue or respond effectively to unrest.

    Shays’ Rebellion in 1786-87 exposed this weakness starkly. At the same time, the delegates had not forgotten why they had rebelled against Britain in the first place. They still feared a distant, unaccountable government that could tax and rule them without meaningful consent.

    Much of their thinking drew on the French philosopher Montesquieu, whose book The Spirit of the Laws (1748) argued that liberty was best protected by dividing government into separate branches.

    James Madison, Alexander Hamilton and John Jay later popularised this reasoning for the American public in the Federalist Papers (1787-88), written to persuade New York to ratify the new Constitution.

    Key terms
    Federalism: the division of political power between a national government and state or regional governments, each with authority over certain matters, such as the US federal government and the fifty state governments.
    Separation of powers: the principle that legislative, executive and judicial power should be held by different, independent institutions, rather than concentrated in one body.
    Checks and balances: the specific powers each branch of government holds over the others, such as the presidential veto or judicial review, designed to stop any one branch dominating.
    Limited government: the idea that government’s power is restricted to only what is specifically granted to it, leaving the rest to individuals or lower levels of government.
    Faction: Madison’s term, in Federalist No. 10, for what we would now often call a political party or interest group. He meant citizens united by a shared interest that may work against the rights of others or the good of the whole community.

    In Federalist No. 10, Madison tackled the danger of faction directly. Rather than trying to eliminate factions, which he thought impossible in a free society, Madison took a different approach. He argued that a large republic with many competing interests would dilute the power of any single faction to dominate.

    It is worth being clear that the Founding Fathers did not design a principle of bipartisanship into the Constitution at all, because the word ‘party’ does not appear anywhere in its text.

    In his Farewell Address of 1796, George Washington explicitly warned against “the baneful effects of the spirit of party,” hoping the new republic could avoid organised political parties altogether. His hope did not survive contact with reality: by the election that followed his retirement, Federalists and Democratic-Republicans were already competing for power.

    Analysis: The Founders’ aims were shaped by two contrasting fears: an overly weak central government, seen under the Articles of Confederation, and an overly powerful one, remembered from British rule. Federalism, separation of powers and limited government were all, in different ways, attempts to hold both fears in balance at once.

    Evaluation: Judged by their own aims, the Founders were only partially successful. Their structural safeguards against concentrated power have proved durable, but their hope of avoiding organised political parties failed almost immediately, showing the limits of designing a political culture through legal text alone.

    Check your understanding
    1. Explain why the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation influenced the design of the Constitution. You could: focus on a specific weakness, such as the inability to raise tax revenue or respond to Shays’ Rebellion, and explain what the Founders changed in response.

    2. To what extent did the Founders succeed in avoiding political parties? You should: state their aim using Washington’s Farewell Address, give a brief account of what actually happened, and reach a judgement about how far the outcome matched the intention.

  • Principles of the US Constitution – Introduction

    The Principles of the US Constitution

    Figure 1: the four principles covered in this document, at a glance.

    “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.”

    James Madison wrote this line in Federalist No. 51 in 1788, as part of a series of essays written to persuade New York to ratify the newly drafted Constitution.

    His point was blunt: rather than trusting politicians to behave well, the Constitution should be built so that self-interested politicians in each branch of government are structurally forced to restrain one another.

    This section of histpology.co.uk tests whether Madison’s claim still holds true today.

    It covers four principles named in the Pearson Edexcel specification:

    • Federalism,
    • Separation of powers and checks and balances
    • Bipartisanship,
    • Limited government.

    For each one, it explains what the principle means and where it comes from in the Constitution’s text. One principle, as we will see, does not come from the text at all. It then shows how each principle has fared in practice, using examples from as recently as 2026.

    Contents

    The main sections of this section are set out below.

    • Reaching a judgement: how effective is the constitutional framework of the USA?

      Madison’s warning in Federalist No. 37, that no language could ever be precise enough to remove all doubt, has proved remarkably accurate. Vagueness, far from weakening the Constitution, has arguably been one of the main reasons it has lasted since 1789 without a full rewrite.

      The case for the current constitutional framework

      • The combination of codification, entrenchment and controlled vagueness has produced one of the most stable and enduring constitutions in the world, with only 27 amendments in well over two centuries.
      • The framework of enumerated and implied powers has allowed the federal government to adapt to challenges the Founding Fathers could not have foreseen, from a national banking system to responses to public health emergencies. This has happened without needing constant formal amendment.
      • Judicial review, though not written into the original text, gives the Constitution a mechanism for updating its meaning that does not depend on the difficult Article V process.

      The case against the current constitutional framework

      • The same vagueness that gives flexibility also produces uncertainty. Supreme Court justices frequently disagree, often along ideological lines, about what the same words require, as seen in the 2025 to 2026 rulings on birthright citizenship and tariff powers.
      • The formal amendment process is now so difficult that popular reforms such as the Equal Rights Amendment and the Flag Desecration Amendment have failed despite significant public and congressional support.
      • So much real change now happens through implied powers and judicial interpretation rather than the text itself. Critics associated with originalism (the view that judges should interpret the Constitution according to its original eighteenth-century meaning) disagree with this trend. They argue that it lets unelected judges, rather than voters or their elected representatives, decide what the Constitution means.

      Reaching a judgement

      AnalysisEvaluation
      Vagueness, codification and entrenchment do not all pull in the same direction.Codification and entrenchment fix the Constitution’s core structure in place, while vagueness quietly lets its meaning evolve underneath that fixed structure, mainly through the Supreme Court rather than through Article V.On balance, this combination has given the United States one of the most durable constitutional frameworks in the world.However, durability has come at the cost of formal responsiveness.When society has wanted rapid, clearly-mandated change, such as guaranteeing equal rights for women, the formal process set out in Article V has consistently proved too difficult to use.
      Check your understanding
      1. Summarise, in no more than five bullet points, the key features that give the US Constitution its distinctive nature. You could: draw one bullet point from each of the three main sections of this document: vagueness/codification/entrenchment, the framework of powers, and the amendment process.

      2. Evaluate the claim that vagueness is more important than codification in explaining why the US Constitution has survived for so long. You should: define both terms briefly, present evidence for and against the claim from this document, and reach a clear judgement rather than presenting both sides with no conclusion.

      3. ‘The US Constitution’s amendment process is its greatest weakness.’ To what extent do you agree, when compared with the flexibility of the UK constitution to adapt to changing circumstances? You should: weigh the advantages and disadvantages of Article V covered above against the ease with which the UK constitution can be changed by Parliament, then reach an explicit judgement rather than simply listing similarities and differences.
    • Extension activities

      The tasks below go beyond what is required for the exam, but they are good preparation for the synoptic (drawing together several topics you have studied), comparative questions that appear in Section C of Paper 3.

      Bookmark this page and revisit these activities at the end of your studies.

      Extension activity 1: separation of powers and checks and balances diagram

      Design a labelled diagram showing the three branches of federal government and the checks each one holds over the other two. Use at least three recent, real-world examples to illustrate the checks in action, rather than describing them only in the abstract.

      Recent event (2025-2026)Branches involvedCheck being exercised
      Trump v. Barbara (30 June 2026): the Supreme Court ruled Donald Trump’s executive order restricting birthright citizenship (the rule that anyone born on US soil automatically becomes a citizen) unconstitutionalJudiciary vs ExecutiveJudicial review of an executive order against the Fourteenth Amendment
      Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump (20 February 2026): the Supreme Court ruled that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does not let the President impose tariffs (taxes on imported goods)Judiciary vs Executive, with Congress’s taxing and commerce powers also at stakeJudicial review restraining a claimed executive power over trade policy
      Trump v. Slaughter (29 June 2026): the Supreme Court struck down legal protections for independent agency heads (officials who run regulatory bodies partly shielded from direct presidential control), letting the President remove the head of the Federal Trade CommissionJudiciary and Executive vs CongressA check being loosened, showing the balance of power can shift in the executive’s favour as well as against it

      Extension activity 2: comparing the US and UK constitutions


      The nature of the UK constitution is covered in detail elsewhere in your A Level and elsewhere on this site, but it is worth starting to compare the two systems now, since Section C of Paper 3 regularly asks synoptic, comparative questions.

      ● Codification: the US Constitution is codified; the UK constitution is uncodified, drawn from statute, common law, convention and authoritative works.
      ● Entrenchment: Article V entrenches the US Constitution; the UK constitution has no equivalent single entrenching mechanism, since Parliament can, in theory, change any part of it by a simple majority.
      ● Source of authority: the US Constitution derives its authority from popular ratification by the states in 1787 and 1788; the UK constitution rests on the principle of parliamentary sovereignty.

      A note on wording: “convention” in US poliitcs usually means a formal assembly (as in a ratifying convention).

      In UK politics, “convention” usually means something different: an unwritten constitutional rule that is followed by tradition rather than law. Keep the two meanings separate when you compare the two systems.


      Using the three prompts above as a starting point, produce your own two-column comparison table of the nature of the US and UK constitutions. Add a short paragraph reaching a judgement on which is more effective at balancing stability with the ability to adapt.

      Extension activity 3: profiling a failed amendment

      Below is a worked example profiling one amendment that passed Congress but failed to be ratified: the Flag Desecration Amendment. Use the same format to profile either the Equal Rights Amendment or the Balanced Budget Amendment as your own extension task.

      YearEvent
      1989In Texas v Johnson, the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 that burning the US flag as a form of political protest is protected speech under the First Amendment.
      1989Congress responded with the Flag Protection Act, an ordinary statute attempting to ban flag burning.
      1990In United States v Eichman, the Supreme Court struck down the Flag Protection Act on the same First Amendment grounds, confirming that only a constitutional amendment could override the ruling.
      1995-2005Versions of a Flag Desecration Amendment passed the House of Representatives several times, but repeatedly failed to reach the two-thirds threshold in the Senate.
      2006The Senate voted 66 to 34 on the amendment, one vote short of the two-thirds majority needed to send it to the states.

      Research the key legal or political turning points, the congressional votes, and any recent developments for either the Equal Rights Amendment or the Balanced Budget Amendment, and present them in the same Year / Event format. Then write a short paragraph explaining what your chosen amendment’s failure reveals about the advantages and disadvantages of the Article V process discussed earlier in this document.

    • Key Amendments to the US Constitution

      Figure 1: the ten amendments of the Bill of Rights, illustrated.

      Article V of the Constitution sets out how it can be amended. An amendment must first be proposed, either by a two-thirds vote in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, or by a national convention called at the request of two-thirds of state legislatures, a method never yet used. It must then be ratified by three-quarters of the states, either through their legislatures or, in one case, through state ratifying conventions. This deliberately high bar means only 27 amendments have been ratified since 1788, out of thousands proposed.

      The table below sets out a selection of the most significant amendments: what each one does, how it was passed, and an evaluation of its lasting significance. The first ten amendments are grouped together as the Bill of Rights, and the Thirteenth to Fifteenth Amendments are grouped as the Reconstruction Amendments, since these are best understood as sets rather than in isolation.

      Summary at a glance

      • Bill of Rights (1791): guarantees core civil liberties, such as free speech, a fair trial and protection from unreasonable search, against the federal government.
      • Reconstruction Amendments (1865-1870): abolished slavery, guaranteed citizenship and equal protection, and banned racial discrimination in voting, following the Civil War.
      • Sixteenth Amendment (1913): gave Congress the power to levy a federal income tax.
      • Eighteenth and Twenty-first Amendments (1919 and 1933): introduced, then fully repealed, the nationwide prohibition of alcohol.
      • Nineteenth Amendment (1920): gave women the right to vote.
      • Twenty-second Amendment (1951): limited presidents to two elected terms in office.
      • Twenty-fifth Amendment (1967): set out clear procedures for presidential succession and disability.

      AmendmentWhat it doesHow it was passedEvaluation of significance
      Bill of Rights (Amendments 1-10, 1791)Ratified together, the first ten amendments are known collectively as the Bill of Rights. They protect core civil liberties against the federal government, including freedom of speech, religion, the press, assembly and petition (First Amendment) and the right to bear arms (Second Amendment). Others protect legal rights: freedom from unreasonable searches (Fourth Amendment), due process and protection against self-incrimination and double jeopardy, being tried twice for the same offence (Fifth Amendment), the right to a fair trial and legal counsel, a lawyer (Sixth Amendment), and protection from cruel and unusual punishment (Eighth Amendment). The Ninth Amendment and Tenth Amendment confirm that rights not listed still belong to the people, and that powers not given to the federal government remain with the states.Proposed by Congress in September 1789 as a package of twelve amendments, two of which were not ratified at the time, and ratified together on 15 December 1791, when Virginia became the eleventh state to approve them.The Bill of Rights is foundational to American civil liberties, but its meaning owes as much to later case law as to its original text. Rulings such as Mapp v Ohio (1961), Gideon v Wainwright (1963), Brandenburg v Ohio (1969) and District of Columbia v Heller (2008) show these amendments still generate significant legal and political argument. It is also worth noting that these protections originally bound only the federal government. They were extended to the states gradually through a process known as incorporation, mainly using the Fourteenth Amendment‘s due process clause.
      Reconstruction Amendments: Thirteenth to Fifteenth (1865-1870)These three amendments, often called the Reconstruction Amendments, followed the Union’s victory in the American Civil War (1861-1865). The Thirteenth Amendment abolishes slavery and involuntary servitude, except as punishment for a crime. The Fourteenth Amendment grants citizenship to all persons born in the United States and guarantees equal protection of the law and due process to all citizens. The Fifteenth Amendment prohibits denying the right to vote on the basis of race, colour, or previous condition of servitude, meaning enslavement.The Thirteenth Amendment was proposed in January 1865 and ratified in December 1865, immediately after the Civil War ended. The Fourteenth Amendment was proposed in 1866 and ratified in 1868, and the Fifteenth was proposed in 1869 and ratified in 1870. Congress required former Confederate states to ratify the Fourteenth Amendment as a condition of re-admission to the Union, giving these amendments an unusually coercive path to ratification.These amendments were a direct constitutional consequence of the Civil War. They entrenched abolition and citizenship in the Constitution itself, making the Union’s victory permanent rather than dependent on ordinary legislation that a later Congress could repeal. In practice, however, their significance was delayed by decades: Southern states used poll taxes, literacy tests and violence to deny Black Americans the vote and equal treatment until the civil rights movement and the Voting Rights Act 1965. This shows that formal constitutional change did not, by itself, guarantee real political or social change.
      Sixteenth Amendment (1913)Gives Congress the power to levy an income tax without apportioning it among the states by population.Proposed on 12 July 1909 and ratified on 3 February 1913, reversing the Supreme Court’s ruling in Pollock v Farmers’ Loan & Trust Co (1895), which had struck down an earlier federal income tax.Transformed the size and reach of the federal government by giving it a reliable, elastic source of revenue. It made possible the expansion of federal programmes across the twentieth century, from the New Deal to modern welfare spending, and so significantly altered the balance of federalism between Washington and the states.
      Eighteenth and Twenty-first Amendments (1919 and 1933)The Eighteenth Amendment prohibited the manufacture, sale and transportation of alcoholic beverages within the United States. The Twenty-first Amendment repealed it in full, ending prohibition.The Eighteenth Amendment was proposed on 18 December 1917 and ratified on 16 January 1919. The Twenty-first Amendment was proposed on 20 February 1933 and ratified on 5 December 1933, becoming the only amendment ratified by state conventions rather than state legislatures.Prohibition is widely judged a policy failure. It fuelled organised crime and widespread law-breaking rather than eliminating alcohol consumption. The Eighteenth Amendment remains the only amendment ever repealed in full, and its repeal shows that the amendment process, though difficult, is not irreversible. Together, the two amendments are a useful case study in the limits of using the Constitution to enforce social morality.
      Nineteenth Amendment (1920)Prohibits denying the right to vote on the basis of sex, extending the vote to women in federal and state elections.Proposed by Congress on 4 June 1919 and ratified on 18 August 1920, when Tennessee became the 36th state to approve it.The amendment was the culmination of a suffrage campaign stretching back to the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848. It significantly expanded the electorate, but its benefits were not shared equally. Many Black women, particularly in the South, remained effectively disenfranchised by the same poll taxes and literacy tests used against Black men under the Fifteenth Amendment, until the Voting Rights Act 1965.
      Twenty-second Amendment (1951)Limits presidents to two elected terms in office.Proposed on 21 March 1947, following Franklin D. Roosevelt’s four elected terms, and ratified on 27 February 1951.Converts a previously informal norm, established by George Washington’s voluntary retirement after two terms, into binding law. It remains politically salient, with periodic, so far unsuccessful, proposals to repeal it in relation to popular presidents.
      Twenty-fifth Amendment (1967)Sets out procedures for presidential succession and for declaring a president unable to discharge the duties of office.Proposed on 6 July 1965, prompted by the constitutional uncertainty following President Kennedy’s assassination in 1963, and ratified on 10 February 1967.Provided clarity previously absent from Article II. Its Section 4, which allows the vice president and cabinet to remove an incapacitated president, has attracted renewed attention amid debate over presidential fitness for office, though it has never actually been invoked for that purpose.

      Table note: dates given are ratification dates unless stated otherwise. Case citations are given in short form (party names and year); full citations can be found via the sources below.