Pearson Edexcel and AQA – Comparative Politics


Below is an overview of how AQA and Pearson Edexcel approach US-UK comparative politics in their A-Level Politics specifications.

Example comparative questions – EDEXCEL

Example comparative questions – AQA


1. Structure of the Courses & Options
FeatureAQA (Specification 7152)Pearson Edexcel (Specification 9PL0)
Comparative ModulePaper 2: Government and Politics of the USA and Comparative PoliticsPaper 3 (Option 3A): Comparative Politics – Government and Politics of the USA
Is it Mandatory?Yes. Every AQA Politics student must study US & UK comparative politics for Paper 2.Optional. Schools choose between 3A (USA) or 3B (Global Politics).

2. Comparative Theoretical Lenses

Both exam boards expect students to use three theoretical approaches when explaining why similarities or differences exist between political systems:

  1. Structural Approach: Explains outcomes through institutions, formal rules, and constitutions (e.g., codified vs. uncodified constitutions, separation of powers vs. fusion of powers).
  2. Rational Choice Approach: Explains outcomes through the self-interested choices and incentives of political actors (e.g., individual politicians, voters, or campaign donors).
  3. Cultural Approach: Explains outcomes through shared history, traditions, ideological values, and national identity (e.g., US individualism vs. UK parliamentary traditions).

3. Exam Assessment Approaches & Question Formats

AQA Assessment Style

  • Explicit Comparative Sections: In Paper 2, questions are specifically broken down into US politics and US-UK comparisons.
  • 12-Mark Short Comparison Questions: Require direct comparative analysis of the UK and US (comparing specific areas like executive power, legislative oversight, or pressure groups) without needing full theoretical framework evaluation.
  • Longer Essays (9 & 25 Marks): Test detailed knowledge of US governance alongside thematic comparisons with the UK.
  • Weighting: The comparative paper makes up 33.3% of the total A-Level.

Pearson Edexcel Assessment Style

Paper 3 makes up 33.3% of the total A-Level, covering both standalone US government content and integrated comparative elements.

While the 30-mark “Evaluate” essays generally focus on evaluating a specific aspect of the US political system in depth (e.g., evaluating the effectiveness of the Electoral College or campaign finance), the short-answer component consists of two distinct 12-mark questions:

Detailed Breakdown: Section A vs. Section B 12-Mark Questions

In both Section A and Section B, the 12-mark questions test AO1 (Knowledge and Understanding) and AO2 (Analysis), split evenly (6 marks each). Neither question tests AO3, meaning you do not need an introduction, a conclusion, or evaluative judgements.

However, their purpose, phrasing, and requirement for Comparative Theory differ significantly:

FeatureSection A (12 Marks)Section B (12 Marks)
Command WordExamine…Analyse…
Question ChoiceChoice of 1 out of 2 questions1 Compulsory question (No choice)
Comparative Theories Required?❌ No.✅ Yes. (Mandatory)
Core FocusComparing specific political features/practices directly between the US and UK.Explaining why similarities or differences exist using comparative theory.

Section A: The “Examine” Question

  • Nature of Question: Asks you to examine the similarities or differences between a specific aspect of US and UK politics (e.g., “Examine the similarities between the powers of the US President and the UK Prime Minister”).
  • What is required: Point-by-point comparative analysis between the US and UK in every paragraph, using detailed knowledge (AO1) and analytical explanation (AO2) of how these features operate.
  • What is NOT required: You do not need to explicitly name or apply comparative theories, nor do you make evaluative judgements.

Section B: The “Analyse” Question (Theoretical Focus)

  • Nature of Question: Asks you to analyse similarities or differences using comparative theories (e.g., “Analyse the differences between US and UK legislative oversight using structural theory”).
  • What is required: You must explicitly integrate comparative theory into your comparative analysis. You can focus on one theory or integrate multiple (Structural, Rational, Cultural) as appropriate to answer the prompt.
  • Theoretical Application:
    • Structural Theory: Explains outcomes through institutions, constitutional rules, and processes (e.g., codified separation of powers vs. fused powers).
    • Rational Choice Theory: Explains outcomes through the self-interest and personal incentives of individual actors (e.g., US members of Congress focusing on re-election in primary-heavy districts vs. UK MPs adhering to party whips).
    • Cultural Theory: Explains outcomes through shared traditions, political heritage, and societal beliefs (e.g., US hyper-individualism vs. UK collective traditions).

4. Key Topic Areas Compared

Across both specifications, comparative study revolves around key themes:

  • Constitutions & Federalism vs. Devolution: Comparing the codified US Constitution and state federalism against the UK’s uncodified constitution and devolved assemblies.
  • Legislatures: US Congress (symmetric bicameralism, strict separation of powers) vs. UK Parliament (asymmetric bicameralism, fusion of powers).
  • Executives: President (Head of State and Government) vs. Prime Minister (Head of Government operating within a constitutional monarchy).
  • Judiciaries & Civil Rights: US Supreme Court (judicial review, constitutional entrenchment, Bill of Rights) vs. UK Supreme Court (parliamentary sovereignty, Human Rights Act declarations of incompatibility).
  • Participation & Democracy: Elections, two-party dominance, third parties, and the role of pressure groups/campaign finance in both nations.